“We’re offering you 3,000 ESOPs.”
For an employee joining a fast-growing company, that sounds exciting.
Your salary might be ₹20 lakh a year, and suddenly your offer letter mentions another number that could potentially be worth several lakhs in the future.
So naturally, the first thought is:
“So, I’m getting 3,000 shares?”
Not exactly.
And that small difference is where the real ESOP story begins.
Let’s say you’re Neha
Neha joins a fast-growing technology company.
As part of her compensation, the company grants her 3,000 ESOPs at an exercise price of ₹100 per share.
She looks at the number and starts doing some quick math:
3,000 × ₹100 = ₹3 lakh
But there is a problem with that calculation.
Neha hasn’t received ₹3 lakh.
In fact, she hasn’t received the 3,000 shares either.
What she has received is a right, subject to the terms of the ESOP scheme, to acquire shares in the future at the specified exercise price.
That distinction is the first thing an employee needs to understand about ESOPs.
So, if Neha doesn’t own the shares yet, when does she actually get the opportunity to acquire them?
That’s where another word enters the picture : Vesting.
Before the shares, there is vesting
Neha goes through her ESOP documents and sees a term she has heard many times: Vesting period.
What does it actually mean?
In simple terms, vesting is the process through which the options granted to an employee become eligible to be exercised, subject to the conditions and schedule of the ESOP plan.
Suppose Neha’s 3,000 options vest over four years.
She doesn’t suddenly get all 3,000 options available for exercise on the day they are granted.
Instead, they become vested according to the schedule set out in the plan.
And then she encounters another term: Cliff.
Suppose the plan has a one-year cliff.
Neha may have to complete the first year before any options vest. After that, the remaining options may vest according to the schedule specified in the plan.
The exact arrangement depends on the company’s ESOP scheme.
So when someone tells you:
“I have been granted 3,000 ESOPs.”
don’t immediately ask:
“How much are they worth?”
Ask:
“How many of them have vested?”
Because those two numbers can be very different.
Three years later, the numbers suddenly look different
Now let’s move Neha’s story forward.
Three years have passed.
The company has grown much faster than expected.
Neha has now 2,250 vested options.
Her exercise price is still ₹100 per share.
But the company’s shares are now valued at ₹600 per share, based on the applicable valuation.
Suddenly, those options look much more exciting.
To exercise all 2,250 vested options, Neha would need to pay:
2,250 × ₹100 = ₹2,25,000
And based on the ₹600 valuation, the shares would be worth:
2,250 × ₹600 = ₹13,50,000
The difference is ₹11.25 lakh.
Neha looks at the numbers and thinks:
“I’ve made ₹11.25 lakh!”
But has she?
Not quite.
She hasn’t received ₹11.25 lakh in cash.
She hasn’t even necessarily realised that value.
She still needs to consider whether and when to exercise the options, the cost of exercise, applicable taxes and—perhaps most importantly—whether she has a practical way to sell the shares.
And that brings us to one of the biggest misunderstandings surrounding ESOPs.
Valuable doesn’t always mean liquid
Imagine Neha exercises her vested options.
She pays ₹2.25 lakh and receives the shares.
On paper, the shares are worth ₹13.5 lakh based on the applicable valuation.
That sounds great.
But there is one problem.
The company is still private.
There is no stock exchange where Neha can simply open an app and sell the shares.
She may own shares that have a significant notional value but are difficult to convert into cash immediately.
There could eventually be a secondary sale, a company buyback, an acquisition or an IPO.
But until an actual liquidity opportunity arises, valuation and cash in hand are two very different things.
That is why employees should be careful about treating an ESOP number as if it were part of their immediate bank balance.
But what if Neha leaves?
Now let’s make the situation a little more complicated.
Suppose Neha resigns after three years.
She has:
2,250 vested options
and
750 unvested options.
What happens now?
There isn’t one universal answer.
The treatment depends on the company’s ESOP scheme and the terms applicable to her exit.
The unvested options may lapse, while the treatment of vested options will depend on the plan’s rules.
And there may be a limited period after leaving during which Neha can exercise her vested options.
Imagine the plan gives her only 30 days.
Suddenly, something that looked like a valuable long-term benefit has become a decision that may require immediate attention.
Neha may need to arrange the exercise money within a short period and also consider the tax consequences.
So don’t wait until the day you resign to ask:
“What happens to my ESOPs if I leave?”
That is a question worth understanding before accepting the ESOP grant.
What if the company gets acquired?
Now let’s change the story again.
Instead of going public, Neha’s company is acquired by a larger company.
Her first reaction might be:
“Great! My ESOPs are finally going to become valuable.”
But again, it isn’t that simple.
There is no single answer to what happens to ESOPs in an acquisition.
The treatment depends on the ESOP scheme and the terms of the transaction.
Depending on the structure, options could potentially be cancelled, replaced, accelerated, settled or otherwise dealt with under the transaction documents.
So if someone tells Neha:
“The company is being acquired. Your ESOPs are worth ₹20 lakh.”
the smart question isn’t:
“When will I get my ₹20 lakh?”
It is:
“What exactly happens to my ESOPs under the acquisition?”
Because a headline valuation does not tell the whole story.
And what if the company goes for an IPO?
An IPO can completely change the liquidity picture.
Once a company becomes listed, there may be a market for its shares, subject to the applicable rules and restrictions.
But even here, the journey isn’t simply:
ESOP → IPO → Cash
The options still need to vest and generally need to be exercised according to the applicable scheme.
There may also be restrictions on selling the resulting shares.
And after listing, the market price can rise—or fall.
So an IPO can create an opportunity to realise value.
It does not guarantee a particular amount of money.
Now let’s go back to the beginning
Remember what Neha was told?
“You have been granted 3,000 ESOPs.”
Sounds impressive.
But what does that statement actually tell her?
Not very much by itself.
To understand what she really has, Neha needs answers to a much longer list of questions:
How many options have vested?
What is the exercise price?
When can she exercise them?
What happens if she leaves the company?
How long does she have to exercise after leaving?
Is the company listed or unlisted?
If she exercises, how can she eventually sell the shares?
What happens if the company is acquired?
What happens if the company goes public?
And what taxes arise along the way?
Only after answering these questions can she begin to understand the real economic value of the ESOPs.
Don’t compare ESOPs just by counting them
Now imagine Neha’s friend receives an offer from another company:
1,000 ESOPs at ₹50
while Neha has:
3,000 ESOPs at ₹100.
At first glance, Neha appears to have the better deal.
Three times as many options.
But that conclusion could be completely wrong.
The number of options is only one piece of the puzzle.
You also need to consider:
•the exercise price,
•the company’s valuation,
•the vesting schedule,
•the total number of shares,
•potential dilution,
•liquidity,
•the terms of the ESOP plan,
•andthe company’s future prospects.
And there is one factor nobody can remove from the equation:
uncertainty.
A company valued at ₹600 per share today may be worth much more in the future.
Or much less.
An ESOP is therefore not simply a calculation based on:
Number of options × today’s valuation.
There is a journey between the two.
Before you get excited about the number, read the terms
If your employer offers you ESOPs,don’t stop at the number written in the offer letter.
Find out:
What exactly has been granted?
What is the exercise price?
How does vesting work?
Is there a cliff?
What happens to unvested options if you leave?
How long can you exercise vested options after leaving?
Is the company listed or unlisted?
How could you eventually sell the shares?
What happens if there is an IPO or acquisition?
And then comes another question—which is important enough to deserve its own discussion:
“What happens tax-wise when I exercise and eventually sell these shares?”
That’s where the story gets even more interesting.
The real meaning of an ESOP
An ESOP can become a very valuable part of an employee’s compensation.
But it is not the same as receiving cash.
And it is not the same as receiving shares immediately.
It is an opportunity whose eventual value depends on what happens between the grant and the eventual sale.
For Neha, the journey looks something like this:
3,000 options granted
↓
Options vest over time
↓
Neha exercises the vested options
↓
Shares are allotted to her
↓
She becomes a shareholder
↓
A liquidity opportunity eventually arises
↓
She sells the shares
↓
She realises whatever value the shares have at that time
And between each of these steps, there can be conditions, costs, risks and tax implications.
The takeaway
If your company tells you:
“You have been granted 3,000 ESOPs.”
don’t immediately ask:
“How much are they worth?”
Ask:
“What exactly do I have, when can I use it, what will it cost me, and how can I eventually turn it into cash?”
Because an ESOP is not a cheque waiting to be deposited.
It is a chance to participate in the future value of the company.
And understanding that difference can make a very big difference to how you value the offer sitting in front of you.
Stox N Tax 
Leave a comment