Stox N Tax

Section 139(9) Income Tax Notice Explained: How to Fix Defective Returns & Avoid Penalties

The Income Tax Department issues notices under various sections to ensure compliance and accuracy in tax filings. One such notice that salaried individuals may receive is under Section 139(9), which indicates that the Income Tax Return (ITR) has been considered defective. This article provides a comprehensive, SEO-optimized guide on understanding, responding to, and preventing errors leading to a Section 139(9) notice.

What is a Notice Under Section 139(9)?

A notice under Section 139(9) is issued when the filed ITR has certain deficiencies, errors, or missing information, making it defective. The taxpayer is required to rectify the issues within the prescribed time to ensure the return is processed correctly. If the errors are not rectified, the return may be deemed invalid, which could result in penalties and legal consequences.

Why Did You Receive a Defective Return Notice?

Understanding the reasons behind a Section 139(9) notice can help taxpayers take corrective action effectively. Here are some common causes:

1. Mismatch Between Form 16 and Filed ITR

Employers issue Form 16, which contains details of your income and tax deductions. If your ITR does not match Form 16, the tax department may classify it as defective.

2. Non-Disclosure of Income

Failing to declare income from sources like fixed deposits, rental income, capital gains, or freelance work may trigger this notice.

3. Incorrectly Claimed Deductions

Deductions under Sections 80C, 80D, HRA, or LTA must match the supporting documents submitted. If deductions exceed eligibility or lack proof, the ITR may be flagged.

4. Use of Wrong ITR Form

Choosing the incorrect ITR form (e.g., using ITR-1 instead of ITR-2 for capital gains or multiple income sources) can make a return defective.

5. Errors in Tax Computation

Discrepancies in tax calculations, exemptions, or missing self-assessment tax payments often lead to an ITR being marked as defective.

6. Missing Financial Statements for Business/Professional Income

Individuals with business or professional income must file a balance sheet and profit & loss statement with their return. Failure to do so results in a Section 139(9) notice.

How to Respond to a Section 139(9) Notice?

Step 1: Log in to the Income Tax Portal

Step 2: Download and Analyze the Notice

  • Find the notice under ‘Defective Return’.
  • Read the details carefully to understand the defect.

Step 3: Choose a Response

Your response depends on whether you agree or disagree with the defect.

If You Agree with the Defect:

  1. Select the correct ITR form based on your income sources.
  2. Recalculate taxable income, deductions, and tax liability.
  3. Submit the revised return under ‘Response to Defective Return’.
  4. Verify the revised return using Aadhaar OTP, Net Banking, or DSC.

If You Disagree with the Defect:

  1. Provide an explanation justifying why your ITR is correct.
  2. Attach supporting documents like Form 16, Form 26AS, and deduction proofs.
  3. Submit your response and wait for department verification.

Step 4: Confirm Submission

  • After submission, check the ‘Response Status’ on the portal.
  • If accepted, the revised return will be processed.

What Happens If You Ignore a Section 139(9) Notice?

Ignoring this notice can have serious consequences:

  • ITR is deemed invalid, requiring you to file a fresh return with penalties.
  • Interest under Sections 234A, 234B, and 234C may be imposed on unpaid tax.
  • Possible tax scrutiny and legal action for non-compliance.

How to Avoid a Section 139(9) Notice in the Future?

To prevent defective returns, follow these best practices:

  1. Cross-check Form 16 and Form 26AS before filing ITR to ensure tax credit accuracy.
  2. Choose the correct ITR form based on your income sources.
  3. Verify deductions and exemptions with valid proofs.
  4. Ensure accurate tax computation using a tax calculator or professional assistance.
  5. Pay self-assessment tax, if applicable, before filing.
  6. File your ITR well before the due date to allow time for corrections.
  7. Keep all supporting documents in case of tax scrutiny.

Key Takeaways

 Section 139(9) notice is not an audit or penalty but a request to correct errors.  Respond within 15 days to avoid invalidation of your return.  Mismatch of income details and deductions is a primary cause of defective returns.  Accurate reporting and timely filing can prevent such notices.  Consulting a tax professional is advised for complex cases.

Final Thoughts

Receiving a Section 139(9) defective return notice can be stressful, but it’s a solvable issue. Understanding why you received the notice, rectifying errors, and following best tax filing practices can help you maintain compliance. If you need expert tax assistance, consulting a professional can simplify the process and prevent future errors.

Leave a comment

Timeline of events