Stox N Tax

ICAI Framework to Combat Financial Frauds in India – A CA’s Perspective

Introduction

In a significant step toward reinforcing the integrity of the financial ecosystem in India, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has unveiled a reinforced framework for detecting, preventing, and responding to financial frauds, as published in its recent press release dated April 2025. This initiative aligns with the global trend of tightening financial regulations and is a testament to ICAI’s commitment toward ethical governance, transparency, and professional accountability.

This article critically analyzes the ICAI’s latest measures from a Chartered Accountant’s lens, covering the legal, procedural, and systemic aspects relevant to corporate India, audit professionals, regulators, and stakeholders.

Background: The Rising Menace of Financial Frauds

Financial frauds in India have seen a sharp uptick over the past decade. According to RBI and SEBI reports, frauds involving misappropriation of funds, accounting manipulations, shell companies, benami transactions, and insider trading have challenged the robustness of internal controls and financial reporting systems.

In response, ICAI has not only played a supervisory role but also acted proactively in issuing accounting advisories, peer reviews, and disciplinary action guidelines. The 2025 framework is a culmination of these experiences and introduces significant enhancements.

Key Pillars of ICAI’s Strengthened Anti-Fraud Framework (2025)

1. Formation of Dedicated Financial Fraud Investigation Cell (FFIC)

ICAI has instituted a Financial Fraud Investigation Cell within its structure, comprising forensic experts, senior CAs, legal consultants, and retired regulators. This body will:

  • Assist in early detection of systemic fraud indicators.
  • Evaluate whistleblower complaints forwarded to ICAI.
  • Coordinate with statutory bodies like SFIO, ED, CBI, SEBI, and RBI.

Legal Basis: The move is in consonance with ICAI’s power under Section 22 of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, which allows for investigation of professional misconduct.

2. Forensic Accounting and Investigation Standards (FAIS)

ICAI has introduced a comprehensive suite of Forensic Accounting and Investigation Standards, which are mandatory for:

  • All forensic audits undertaken by members in practice.
  • Fraud investigation reports submitted to courts and regulators.

These standards cover:

  • Evidence collection and chain of custody.
  • Interview techniques and behavioral red flags.
  • Data analytics and use of AI/ML in fraud detection.

Applicability: These FAIS are binding under ICAI’s Code of Ethics and are to be followed by any CA engaged in a forensic or investigative assignment.

3. Mandatory Fraud Reporting for Large Assignments

All auditors engaged for statutory audits of:

  • Listed companies
  • Unlisted companies with turnover above ₹250 crores
  • Financial institutions

…are now mandated to submit a Fraud Risk Evaluation Report to the audit committee and, if material fraud is suspected, to report to NFRA and ICAI under Section 143(12) of the Companies Act, 2013.

ICAI will use this data to create a Fraud Heat Map for specific sectors, highlighting vulnerabilities.

4. Centralized Database of Fraudulent Entities

In collaboration with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, ICAI is now maintaining a real-time digital repository of:

  • Disqualified directors (under Section 164 of Companies Act)
  • Entities blacklisted by regulators
  • Companies flagged for audit manipulation

This initiative will help Chartered Accountants perform due diligence before accepting any audit or consultancy engagement, especially under SA 240 (The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements).

5. Strengthening Peer Review and QRB Mechanisms

The Peer Review Board (PRB) and Quality Review Board (QRB) are now empowered to:

  • Undertake suo motu reviews for suspected audit failures.
  • Use AI-driven risk parameters to select audit firms for surprise inspections.
  • Publish redacted reports highlighting systemic failures and learning points.

As per revised guidelines, peer reviews for firms conducting audits of listed entities will be mandatory every 3 years instead of the earlier 4-year cycle.

6. Whistleblower and Public Grievance Mechanism for Professional Misconduct

ICAI has launched a dedicated portal for lodging misconduct complaints against Chartered Accountants, whether in practice or in employment. Complainants can:

  • Anonymously submit complaints under adequate documentation.
  • Track the status via unique complaint IDs.
  • Seek compensation or redressal for professional negligence.

This system reinforces transparency and aligns with ICAI’s disciplinary procedure under Chapter V of the CA Act.

Implications for Practicing Chartered Accountants

  • Higher Documentation Standards: With greater scrutiny on forensic audits and fraud detection, CAs must document risk assessments and fraud procedures diligently, especially under SA 315 and SA 330.
  • Professional Indemnity Insurance: ICAI’s guidance recommends CAs to obtain professional indemnity insurance, particularly those handling high-risk engagements.
  • Increased Risk of Disciplinary Action: Non-compliance with FAIS, failure to report fraud, or lapses in audit execution may now result in stricter penalties including suspension or cancellation of membership.
  • New Opportunities: On the brighter side, these changes open up new service verticals like forensic audits, corporate investigations, whistleblower evaluations, and third-party fraud due diligence.

Legal and Regulatory Harmony

This ICAI initiative dovetails with concurrent actions by:

  • SEBI: Strengthening audit trail and internal financial control disclosures.
  • RBI: Guidelines on fraud monitoring in NBFCs and co-operative banks.
  • MCA: Revised CARO 2020 reporting with emphasis on frauds, whistleblowers, and fund diversion.
  • NFRA: Intensified oversight on statutory auditors and audit documentation.

Conclusion

The ICAI’s fortified framework against financial frauds is both timely and necessary. As custodians of financial truth, Chartered Accountants are pivotal in upholding trust in the corporate and financial systems. This initiative not only raises the bar for audit quality but also enhances India’s global standing in ethical financial practices and regulatory compliance.

CAs must now walk the talk — shifting from passive compliance to active deterrence and detection — making the profession a central pillar in India’s war against financial fraud.

Leave a comment

Timeline of events